Why I Love Calling Plantation Key Home
As a Plantation Key resident and real estate expert, I can confidently say that this little slice of the Upper Florida Keys is one of the best places to live. It offers the perfect mix of laid-back island living with the conveniences you need for everyday life. Whether you’re looking for a quiet neighborhood to settle down in or an investment property with rental potential, Plantation Key has something for everyone.
The Real Estate Market in Plantation Key
Plantation Key’s real estate market is as diverse as the island itself, ranging from charming homes in neighborhoods like Plantation Key Colony to luxurious waterfront estates with private docks. Here’s a look at what’s happening in the market right now:
- Current Listings: As of early 2025, there are around 100 active residential listings in Plantation Key.
- Pricing Trends: The average sale price has jumped by 12.94% year-over-year, now sitting at approximately $2.95 million, which speaks to the high demand for homes in the area.
- Days on Market: Homes are taking a bit longer to sell, averaging 88 days on the market, which is still competitive compared to other Florida Keys locations.
- Sale-to-List Price Ratio: On average, homes sell for about 92.7% of their original listing price, showing there’s still some room for negotiation but demand remains strong.
Why Plantation Key is a Fantastic Place to Live
If you’re thinking about making Plantation Key your home, here are some things I love most about living here:
- Top-Rated Schools: Families love the area for its highly rated schools, including Plantation Key School (PKS) and Coral Shores High School. The quality of education makes this one of the best spots in the Florida Keys for raising kids.
- Outdoor Lifestyle: Whether you love boating, fishing, paddleboarding, or just watching the sunset over the bay, Plantation Key is a dream for water lovers.
- Tight-Knit Community: The neighborhoods here have a true sense of community. Plantation Key Colony, for example, is known for its friendly neighbors and great location with easy access to everything.
- Centralized Location: Plantation Key is a short drive from both Key Largo and Islamorada, making it a great option for those who who may need to commute in the Upper Keys.
Is Plantation Key a Good Investment?
Absolutely! The demand for Florida Keys real estate remains high, and Plantation Key offers great investment potential. Here’s why:
- Vacation Rentals: Monthly and annual rentals are always in demand, especially with the area’s easy access to boating and fishing spots.
- Property Value Appreciation: Home values in Plantation Key continue to rise, making it a smart long-term investment.
- Rental Market Strength: If you’re considering an investment property, I can help you navigate the best areas and rental strategies to maximize your return.
Let’s Find Your Dream Home on Plantation Key
Whether you’re looking for a primary residence, a vacation getaway, or an investment opportunity, I can help you find the perfect Plantation Key home. As a local resident and real estate expert, I know this island inside and out. Let’s explore your options together and find a home that fits your lifestyle and goals.
Ready to make the move? Contact me today, and let’s talk about the possibilities!
Natalie Biondoletti, Broker Associate
